Page 1 of 3

Three penalties

Posted: Mon Aug 16, 2010 2:03 pm
by ScottishFA
After Paul Hartley's feat on Saturday, I was curious about the previous players to have scored a treble of penalties in Scotland. I've come up with the following list - any more suggestions?

Eddie Turnbull (Hibs 4 Celtic 1, 4 February 1950)
Bobby Collins (Celtic 3 Aberdeen 0, 26 September 1953)
Billy Price (Falkirk 3 Hamilton Accies 2, 8 August 1959 (LC))
Gordon Wallace (Montrose 4 Hamilton Accies 2, 20 April 1963)
Donald Ford (Morton 2, Hearts 3, 1 September 1973)
Bobby McKean (St Mirren 3 Brechin 0, 16 February 1974)
Gerry Colgan (Queen's Park 3 Brechin 1, 18 September 1976)

Posted: Mon Aug 16, 2010 2:25 pm
by qpsnapper
According to the Sun this morning, it's been done nine times in Scotland, don't have their list to hand unfortunately, but from memory they said the last time was an Albion Rovers player in 1996.

However, their list omitted Stevie Reilly scoring three from the spot for Queen's Park against Elgin City at Hampden on 16th August 2003 in a league match.

Posted: Mon Aug 16, 2010 5:38 pm
by LEATHERSTOCKING
The Albion Rovers player was Dougie McGuire vs. Arbroath League Cup 1st Round 2rd August 1996. David Lindsay(St.Mirren) vs. Rangers Division One on 9th January 1904 was the first. It`s been done 13 times in senior football in league, Cup & League Cup.

Posted: Mon Aug 16, 2010 5:38 pm
by LEATHERSTOCKING
Sorry, I clicked too quickly(story of my life!); it`s 14 times now with Paul Hartley`s on Saturday.

Posted: Tue Aug 17, 2010 3:53 pm
by bungle1979
Apologies - tried to find the list but doesn't seem to be on the Scottish Sun website.

Am I right in thinking that Donald Ford would be the last top-flight player to score a hat-trick of penalties in Scotland?

I've got gaps in my Rothmans yearbooks so cannot say definitively myself.

Posted: Tue Sep 21, 2010 10:20 am
by qpsnapper
Another one to add to the list with Mark Roberts scoring three times from the spot for Ayr United against East Fife on Saturday.

An interesting day for him as it seems he proceeded to get involved in an altercation with an opposition player after the third and got sent off!

Posted: Tue Sep 21, 2010 11:18 am
by Scottish
Safe to say that Mark Roberts is the first to score a penalty hat-trick AND get sent off.

Oddly enough, Mark Roberts made his debut, aged 15, as a substitute for Kilmarnock v Meadowbank in a Scottish Cup tie on Feb 4th 1991 and proceeded to miss from the spot in the penalty shoot-out. Tommy Burns also missed and Meadowbank won 4-3 to leave Killie with the dubious honour of being the first team to lose a Scottish Cup tie twice on penalties, having managed to become the first side to do so the previous year v Stranraer.

Who mentioned the good old days?

Re: Three penalties

Posted: Tue Oct 26, 2010 7:02 am
by Bristol Rovers
The Mark Roberts case is similar to the Damian Spencer story in some respects. He came on as sub for Cheltenham Town at home to MK Dons, 31 Jan 2009. His side trailed 5-0, then he scored a hat-trick and was then sent off. Cheltenham lost 5-3.

As I understand it, Forfar Athletic were awarded four separate penalties, 16 Oct 2010, in their 4-1 win at home to Ayr United. Ross Campbell scored (12 mins) and missed (75 mins), Scott Allan missed (76 mins) and sub Martyn Fotheringham (81 mins) scored. I know Burnley (1909) and Crystal Palace (1989) have both been awarded four separate (ie not including retaken) penalties in a League game in England. Is this the first such instance in the Scottish League?

Re: Three penalties

Posted: Tue Oct 26, 2010 12:12 pm
by LEATHERSTOCKING
Four penalty kicks have been awarded in a single game seven times in Scotland as far as I`m aware. The 1st instance I can find was St.Mirren vs. Rangers Division One 9/1/1904 - David Lindsay(St.Mirren) scored 3 and Bob Hamilton(Rangers) scored too. Lindsay was the 1st player to net a hat-trick of spot kicks.

Re: Three penalties

Posted: Thu Oct 28, 2010 10:56 am
by Bristol Rovers
LEATHERSTOCKING wrote:Four penalty kicks have been awarded in a single game seven times in Scotland as far as I`m aware. The 1st instance I can find was St.Mirren vs. Rangers Division One 9/1/1904 - David Lindsay(St.Mirren) scored 3 and Bob Hamilton(Rangers) scored too. Lindsay was the 1st player to net a hat-trick of spot kicks.
Thank you, Leatherstocking. Do you or does anyone else have a list of the other five instances prior to last week's game?

Re: Three penalties

Posted: Mon Apr 16, 2012 10:01 am
by qpsnapper
Looking through the Herald and Scotsman archives today and I came across another example of this that I hadn't seen mentioned before, although it may be included in Leatherstocking's figure of fourteen occurances mentioned above.

It's Herd of Hamilton Accies scoring three penalties against Partick Thistle on 07/01/1933, Accies winning 4-3.

Re: Three penalties

Posted: Mon Apr 16, 2012 1:18 pm
by Skyline Drifter
Four penalties given in the Rangers v St Mirren game from 7th April 2012 too obviously.

Sone Aluko and Lee McCulloch failed for Rangers. Kyle Lafferty scored. Paul McGown scored for St Mirren.

Re: Three penalties

Posted: Mon Apr 16, 2012 3:22 pm
by Scottish
Don't forget the three clear penalties denied to Celtic in every match they lose.

Re: Three penalties

Posted: Wed Apr 18, 2012 8:02 am
by Bristol Rovers
This is what I have on Scottish League games where four penalties have been awarded. Please add to this list ...

9.1.1904 St Mirren v Rangers – David Lindsay (St M) scored 3 pens, RC Hamilton (Rangers) scored one pen
24.9.1927 Dumbarton (2)4 King’s Park (2)5 – Urquhart (Dumb) scored 3 pens, Tanner (KP) scored pen
25.2.1928 Queen’s Park 5 Kilmarnock 1 – QP scored 2 pens, Kilm scored one, missed one
2.9.1931 Dundee 2 Ayr Utd 2 – Dundee scored pen, Ayr scored two pens, missed one
15.2.1936 Leith Ath 4 Cowdenbeath 2 – White (LA) scored two pens, Mair (LA goalkeeper) saved two Cowdenbeath pens
1.1.1987 Morton 4 Dumbarton 1 – John McNeil scored 2 pens, Rowan Alexander scored one pen (Morton), Dumbarton penalty scored
28.9.2002 Queen’s Park 2 Albion R 4 – QP scored one, missed one; AR scored two
16.8.2003 Queen’s Park 5 Elgin C 3 – apparently only time in Scottish Lge five pens awarded – Stevie Reilly scored three pens for QP
18.9.2010 E Fife (2)2 Ayr Utd (2)3 – Rob Sloan scored pen (EF); Mark Roberts (AU) scored 3 pens
6.10.10 Forfar Ath 4 Ayr U 1 – Forfar awarded four pens – Ross Campbell scored, missed, Scott Allan missed; Martyn Fotheringham scored
7.4.2012 Rangers 3 St Mirren 1 – 3 pens to Rangers, Sone Aluko missed, Lee McCulloch missed, Kyle Lafferty scored; Paul McGowan scored pen for St Mirren

Re: Three penalties

Posted: Wed Apr 18, 2012 8:50 am
by LEATHERSTOCKING
The 1928 Queen`s vs. Killie game in Division One ended 5-3 not 5-1 for Queen`s. J.B.(Mutt) McAlpine scored with one penalty and netted with a rebound off the Killie `keeper with another. I don`t have the name(s) of Killie penalty taker(s) or of their `keeper I`m afraid. David?